Five records that went from hidden gems to cult classics


When it comes to music, critical acclaim doesn't always translate to popularity (just look at the comments around some Pitchfork reviews...). In fact, some of the most beloved albums of all time were initially overlooked by critics and the mainstream audience. These hidden gems went on to become cult favorites, cherished by music fans around the world. Let's take a closer look at five such albums that defied expectations and achieved legendary status.

1. "The Velvet Underground & Nico" by The Velvet Underground

Released in 1967, "The Velvet Underground & Nico" was met with mixed reviews and poor sales. However, its experimental sound and provocative lyrics resonated with a small but dedicated group of fans. Over time, the album gained recognition for its influence on alternative rock and is now considered one of the greatest albums of all time.

2. "In the Aeroplane Over the Sea" by Neutral Milk Hotel

Upon its release in 1998, "In the Aeroplane Over the Sea" received little attention from mainstream music critics. However, indie music enthusiasts quickly embraced its unique blend of folk, psychedelic rock, and lo-fi aesthetics. Today, the album is hailed as a masterpiece and a cornerstone of the indie folk genre.

3. "Pink Moon" by Nick Drake

When "Pink Moon" was released in 1972, it went virtually unnoticed. Nick Drake's introspective lyrics and minimalist acoustic arrangements didn't fit the popular music trends of the time. It wasn't until years later, after Drake's tragic death, that the album gained a cult following. Today, "Pink Moon" is regarded as a hauntingly beautiful and influential work.

4. "Surfer Rosa" by Pixies

Despite its raw energy and innovative songwriting, "Surfer Rosa" failed to make a significant impact upon its release in 1988. However, its influence on alternative rock and grunge cannot be overstated. The album's mix of loud-quiet dynamics, surreal lyrics, and aggressive guitar work laid the groundwork for the alternative music explosion of the 1990s.

5. "Ys" by Joanna Newsom

When "Ys" was released in 2006, it divided critics and listeners alike. Joanna Newsom's intricate harp playing and idiosyncratic vocals were not easily accessible. However, those who delved into the album's complex arrangements and poetic storytelling were rewarded with a truly unique musical experience. Today, "Ys" is celebrated as a modern folk masterpiece.

These albums are just a glimpse into the world of cult favorites. They serve as a reminder that true artistic brilliance can sometimes go unnoticed at first. At Gold Records USA, we understand the value of these hidden gems. That's why we offer a service to turn any record into gold, including these fan-favorite albums. We believe that every artist deserves the attention and reverence they deserve, no matter how long it takes.

Back to blog